Ed – Page 176 – The Smell of Molten Projects in the Morning

MTD Snowthrower: Friction Wheel Tire Replacement

Late in last winter’s snowfall, our MTD snowthrower / snowblower ran low on get-up-and-go mobility, so I resolved to check inside before the next snowfall. What with one thing and another, time passed until, a few days before the first major snowfall of this winter season, I opened the bottom cover and found this mess:

Snowthrower friction wheel - worn in place — Snowthrower friction wheel – worn in place

Oops.

A diagram from the manual identifies the components:

MTD Snowblower - drive train - Fig 23 — MTD Snowblower – drive train – Fig 23

The 8 HP gas engine spins the drive plate, which transfers some of those horses through the rubber tire on the friction wheel to the gear shaft, which turns the axle attached to the wheels. The shift lever (not shown) moves the friction wheel along the shaft to change the “gear ratio” setting the ground speed, with five positions to the right of the plate center going forward and two on the left going in reverse.

It’s a modern implementation of the classic Lambert friction drive transmission from a century ago. Cheap, effective, nothing wrong with it other than requiring regular inspection and preventive maintenance.

Unfortunately, the rubber tire seems undersized for the task and had completely worn away, leaving its steel rim to chew on the drive plate:

Snowthrower friction wheel - scarred drive plate — Snowthrower friction wheel – scarred drive plate

Of course, you’re supposed to inspect the situation more regularly than I (and, most likely, anyone) ever have. I vaguely recall replacing the tire once before and, being that type of guy, ordered two to have a spare on the shelf. Anyhow, it was in fine shape the last time I checked to see what shape it was in.

The manual recommends loosening (but not removing) the hex nut on the left side of the gear shaft:

Then “lightly tap the hex nut to dislodge the ball bearing”. Well, it’s a nylon lock nut, not a plain hex nut, which means pounding the crimp holding the nylon ring on the nut will destroy it. I whacked the end of the shaft with a plastic hammer to no avail, removed the nut & washer, and gave it a few careful shots with a 2 lb ball peen hammer, also to no avail.

The basic problem comes down to having the bearing mounted in what’s basically a sheet metal wall of no particular substance: banging on the shaft deflects the wall and moves the bearing along with the shaft. As far as I could tell, the shaft was stuck inside the bearing race, so I soaked it in pentrating oil while pondering the next step overnight.

A few more shots with the hammer convinced me that wasn’t going to work and would likely damage the threads, so I made a pair of Special Service Tools:

Snowthrower friction wheel - homebrew removal tools — Snowthrower friction wheel – homebrew removal tools

The smaller one fits around the threaded end of the shaft and inside the inner race to apply the impact directly to the shaft instead of the threads. The larger one fits on the inner race itself, in the expectation I would need to persuade it, but it wasn’t necessary. They both started life as iron pipe, covered in what looks like aluminumized paint for no reason we’ll ever know, and faced in the lathe.

The combination of penetrating oil, a proper SST, and some diligent whacking popped the shaft out of the bearing without damage. The friction wheel assembly then slid off the shaft with no resistance and the shaft and right-side bearing slid easily out of the frame. Once in the shop, gentle filing knocked the rust & burrs off the shaft and let it slide freely into the bearing.

The friction wheel clamps the tire with six bolts, three from each side so MTD can use a single part number for the halves:

Snowthrower friction wheel - screw pattern — Snowthrower friction wheel – screw pattern

It came apart easily, the new tire went on easily, the drive assembly went back together easily, and the blower cleared more than a foot of snow from the driveway:

Mary running snowthrower - 2020-12-17 — Mary running snowthrower – 2020-12-17

Nothing can make maneuvering a snowblower easy, alas.

I briefly thought of refacing the drive plate, but I’m pretty sure it comes heartbreakingly close to Tiny Lathe’s limited swing. With two spare tires on the shelf, should the scarred plate chew up the new tire in one season, I’ll make better measurements.

2020-12-24

MTD Snowthrower: Replacement Throttle Knob

The throttle knob on our MTD snowthrower (a.k.a. snowblower) cracked apart around its metal shaft when I pulled it upward. A temporary fix involving duct tape and cable ties sufficed to start the engine, although the usual intense vibration shook the knob loose somewhere along the driveway during the next hour.

Update: Found it!

Although I have no photographic evidence, I did make a few quick measurements:

It fits an MTD model E6A4E, but I suspect nearly all their engines have identical throttle shafts:

Snowthrower Throttle Knob - stem end - solid model — Snowthrower Throttle Knob – stem end – solid model

The only practical way to build the thing has it standing on the shaft end, surrounded by a brim to improve adhesion, so I added (actually, subtracted) a pair of holes for music-wire reinforcements:

Snowthrower throttle knob - reinforcing wires — Snowthrower throttle knob – reinforcing wires

It definitely has a stylin’ look, next to the original choke control knob:

Snowthrower throttle knob - installed — Snowthrower throttle knob – installed

I omitted the finger grip grooves for obvious reasons.

The slot-and-hole came out slightly smaller than the metal shaft and, rather than wait for epoxy to cure, I deployed a 230 W soldering gun (not a piddly temperature-controlled iron suitable for electronics) on the shaft and melted it into the knob.

More snow may arrive this week and I printed another knob just in case …

The OpenSCAD source code as a GitHub Gist:

	// MTD Snowthrower Throttle Knob
	// Ed Nisley KE4ZNU 2020-12-18

	/* [Options] */
	Layout = "Show"; // [Build, Show]


	// Extrusion parameters
	/* [Hidden] */

	ThreadThick = 0.25;
	ThreadWidth = 0.40;

	HoleWindage = 0.2;

	Protrusion = 0.1; // make holes end cleanly

	inch = 25.4;

	function IntegerMultiple(Size,Unit) = Unit * ceil(Size / Unit);

	//———————-
	// Dimensions

	Throttle = [17.0,1.85,6.5]; // blade insertion, thickness, width

	PaddleSize = [25,30,9];
	PaddleRound = 4.0;
	PaddleThick = 8.5;

	StemDia = 13.0;
	StemLength = 20.0;

	PinDia = 1.6;
	PinLength = PaddleSize.x + StemLength/2;
	echo(str("Pin: ",PinLength," x ",PinDia," mm"));

	//———————-
	// Useful routines

	module PolyCyl(Dia,Height,ForceSides=0) { // based on nophead's polyholes

	Sides = (ForceSides != 0) ? ForceSides : (ceil(Dia) + 2);

	FixDia = Dia / cos(180/Sides);

	cylinder(r=(FixDia + HoleWindage)/2,
	h=Height,
	$fn=Sides);
	}

	//———————-
	// Pieces

	module Paddle() {


	difference() {
	hull() {
	translate([PaddleSize.x/2,0,0]) {
	for (i=[-1,1], j=[-1,1])
	translate([i(PaddleSize.x – PaddleRound)/2,j(PaddleSize.y – PaddleRound)/2,0])
	sphere(d=PaddleRound,$fn=12);
	rotate([0,90,0]) rotate(180/12)
	cylinder(d=PaddleThick,h=PaddleSize.x,,center=true,$fn=12);
	}
	translate([-StemLength,0,0])
	rotate([0,90,0]) rotate(180/12)
	cylinder(d=StemDia,h=Throttle.x,center=false,$fn=12);
	}

	translate([-StemLength,0,0])
	cube([2*Throttle.x,Throttle.y,Throttle.z],center=true);
	translate([-(StemLength + Protrusion),0,0])
	rotate([0,90,0]) rotate(0*180/6)
	PolyCyl(2*Throttle.y,Throttle.x,6);

	for (j=[-1,1])
	translate([-StemLength/2,j*PaddleSize.y/6,0])
	rotate([0,90,0]) rotate(180/4)
	PolyCyl(PinDia,PinLength,4);
	}
	}




	//———————-
	// Build it

	if (Layout == "Show")
	Paddle();


	if (Layout == "Build") {
	translate([0,0,StemLength])
	rotate([0,-90,0])
	Paddle();
	}

view raw Snowthrower Throttle Knob.scad hosted with ❤ by GitHub

2020-12-22

Makergear M2: Platform Z=0 and Alignment Check

After replacing the nozzle and filament drive on the M2, it’s definitely time to verify that the Z=0 point remains at the platform surface and the whole affair is properly aligned.

Distribute five thinwall open squares across the platform:

Calibration Boxes - platform alignment - 2020-12-11 — Calibration Boxes – platform alignment – 2020-12-11

Because they’re well separated and only 3 mm tall, I set Slic3r to print them sequentially to eliminate a whole bunch of back-and-forth travel for each layer.

Print and measure the results:

Calibration Boxes - initial M206 Z-2.50 - 2020-12-11 — Calibration Boxes – initial M206 Z-2.50 – 2020-12-11

The outer numbers come from the skirt around the whole platform in units of 0.01 mm: 22 → 0.22 mm. The five inner numbers are the eyeballometric average of four measurements across each square.

They came short enough that adding 0.25 mm to their height would improve the outcome. The scribbles in the upper right corner show the initial Z offset was -2.50 mm, which means -2.75 mm should do the trick; remember to save the new value in EEPROM with M500.

Print the same G-Code file with the new offset and measure:

Calibration Boxes - M206 Z-2.75 - 2020-12-11 — Calibration Boxes – M206 Z-2.75 – 2020-12-11

Can’t get much closer than that!

The skirt gains only 0.1 mm for reasons unknown to me. It’s a good diagnostic tool for keeping an eye on the overall alignment without having to run more calibration squares, though.

Comparing the center squares (bottom layers facing each other in the middle) from the two sets shows the difference:

Test Squares 2.73 3.01 mm - 2020-12-11 — Test Squares 2.73 3.01 mm – 2020-12-11

The bottom three layers got pretty well squashed with the previous offset. It’s missing about a full layer, although the nozzle wasn’t mashed flat / blocked against the platform. All the layers in the post-adjustment square look identical, as they should.

The wall thickness on the latter squares runs from 0.40 to 0.44 mm, with an eyeballometric average around 0.43, so tweaking the Extrusion Multiplier down by maybe 5% would be in order if I were being fussy.

Overall, not bad for a new setup!

2020-12-14

Turkey Baster FAIL

We bought a generic Walmart-grade baster perhaps two years ago to replace a much older one with a failed rubber bulb. We use it intermittently throughout the year and had a turkey in the oven when we discovered this:

Cracked Baster - overview — Cracked Baster – overview

A closer look at the business end:

Cracked Baster - tip detail — Cracked Baster – tip detail

Yes, those cracks go all the way through, there’s a loose spear running the length of the thing, and it definitely doesn’t work as a baster.

Contrary to what you might think from the general fogging and stress cracking, I haven’t used it for gasoline or brake fluid, nor do we put it away without washing it.

The rubber bulb still works fine, though, so there’s that.

We’ll up our spend for an OXO baster and see what happens.

2020-12-13

Makergear M2: New Filament Drive and Guide Tube Adapter

After replacing the M2’s nozzle, I also installed a spare filament drive:

Makergear M2 filament drive R3 - installed — Makergear M2 filament drive R3 – installed

That’s the V4 R3 version, although I bought it from Makergear rather than fight with all the support required to get a proper bearing opening.

The long M4 screw and spring apply a constant force to the filament against the drive gear, rather than the constant position from the default (and much shorter) stock screw. The lever arm does have some springiness, but not much travel, so IMO the spring works better with the fine teeth in the drive gear.

This drive has a 5 mm hole at the top for the stock PTFE guide tube, which I long ago replaced with ¼ inch OD HDPE tubing to reduce the friction required to get the filament off the spool and into the hot end. The rather hideous hot-melt glue blob holding a ¼ inch ID tube onto the previous drive never failed enough to bother me, but a little lathe action produced a much better adapter:

Makergear M2 filament drive R3 - guide adapter — Makergear M2 filament drive R3 – guide adapter

It’s a chunk of ⅜ inch = 9.5 mm Delrin rod with a 2.4 mm hole through that 5 mm spigot for easy extraction of a gear-mashed 1.75 mm filament. The other end has a 6.5 mm hole drilled 20 mm deep to hold the guide tube.

Looks downright dressy, it does!

2020-12-11

Makergear M2: New Nozzle

A second clog in the M2’s hot end prompted me to dismantle the hot end:

Makergear M2 V4 hot end - eroded silicone coat — Makergear M2 V4 hot end – eroded silicone coat

That’s what half a year of use does to a nice, shiny coat of high-temperature silicone rubber.

This being the first time I’ve dismantled the hot end, here’s what lies inside:

Makergear M2 V4 hot end - tapered inner guide — Makergear M2 V4 hot end – tapered inner guide

The tighter you make the nozzle, the closer the fit inside the hot end, and the more heat gets transferred to the plastic. The bright ring just to the right of the plastic drool shows where it fits into the brass nozzle.

Peeling the remaining silicone off the nozzle, scraping off the black PETG around the tip, and scraping the gunk out left the inside a bit scuffed:

Makergear 0.35 mm nozzle - interior — Makergear 0.35 mm nozzle – interior

The orifice still looks good and is still as close to 0.35 mm as I can measure eyeballometrically:

Makergear 0.35 mm nozzle - exterior — Makergear 0.35 mm nozzle – exterior

Despite what it looks like, that’s actually a very thin PETG layer.

Having a spare nozzle on the shelf, I decided to install it and leave the old nozzle as a backup. I’ve probably wrecked the snug seal required to keep the plastic out of the hot end.

A fresh coat of silicone, reset the position with the platform at Z=0, and it’s back in action:

Makergear M2 V4 hot end - Z zero set — Makergear M2 V4 hot end – Z zero set

The PETG remnants show I didn’t get the nozzle quite tight enough on the first attempt, but it’s all good now. The rubbery fiberglass insulator will conceal the mess.

Protip: Always remove the hot end from the printer and clamp it securely before unscrewing the nozzle, because the very thin heat break (over on the right in the second picture) will snap under less torque than you need to break the nozzle free.

You should unscrew the nozzle with the hot end warm enough to soften whatever plastic you’re using, lest it have glued everything inside into a solid lump.

2020-12-10

Drive Wheelchair Brake Knob

The bent-steel brake levers on our Drive Blue Streak wheelchair present themselves edge-on to the rider:

There are good mechanical reasons for shaping and orienting the steel like that, but the handle concentrates the considerable force required to push the brake tab into the rubberoid tire on your (well, my) palms. After a couple of weeks, I decided I didn’t need two more sore spots and conjured a palm-filling knob from the vasty digital deep:

Wheelchair Brake Knob - installed — Wheelchair Brake Knob – installed

Bonus part: the little octagon near the wheel prevents the leg rest (seen in the first picture) from smashing into the end of the brake tab and chipping the lovely blue powder coat. The brown fuzzy felt foot seemed like a good idea at the time, but isn’t strictly necessary.

A cylindrical handle on Thingiverse apparently fits on the bare steel underneath the rubberish “cushion”, but cutting a perfectly good, albeit uncomfortable, cushion off seemed like a step in the wrong direction. My knob thus descends from a doodle of the OEM dimensions:

Drive Wheelchair Brake Handle - dimensions — Drive Wheelchair Brake Handle – dimensions

The knob builds in two halves adjoining the bonus octagon, which stands on edge to eliminate support inside its slot:

Wheelchair Brake Mods - solid model - build layout — Wheelchair Brake Mods – solid model – build layout

You (probably) need two of all those shapes, a job your slicer is ready to perform. At three hours for each knob, I just printed the same G-Code twice.

You can customize the knob width to fit your palm, with the other two dimensions fitting themselves around the cushion. Mary and I settled on a knob size that fits both our hands reasonably well, so it’s probably not critical.

I tried building the knob halves without support for the first prototype, but the sloped upper surface produced awful bridging:

Wheelchair Brake Knob - unsupported interior — Wheelchair Brake Knob – unsupported interior

It’s easy enough to design a customized support structure:

Wheelchair Brake Mods - cross section — Wheelchair Brake Mods – cross section

I oriented the knob to put the split on the narrow sides of the brake handle in order to not have a seam facing my palm:

Wheelchair Brake Knob - rear half installed — Wheelchair Brake Knob – rear half installed

The quartet of M3×20 mm socket-head cap screws thread into brass inserts epoxied into the rear half. I recessed their heads deeply into the front half and avoided thinking too hard about plugs matching the surface curvature:

Wheelchair Brake Knob - front view — Wheelchair Brake Knob – front view

The low-vertex-count polygonal shape is a stylin’ thing and produces a nice feel during a firm shove, at least to my paws. Although I’d rather not need a wheelchair at all, setting the brakes now seems authoritative instead of annoying.

The OpenSCAD source code as a GitHub gist:

	// Pride wheelchair brake lever mods
	// Ed Nisley KE4ZNU 2020-11

	/* [Layout options] */

	Layout = "Build"; // [Build, Show, Fit, TabCap, Handle, Knob, Support]

	// Hold up the knob's inside
	Support = true;

	/* [Extrusion parameters] */

	/* [Hidden] */

	ThreadThick = 0.25;
	ThreadWidth = 0.40;

	HoleWindage = 0.2;

	function IntegerMultiple(Size,Unit) = Unit * ceil(Size / Unit);
	function IntegerLessMultiple(Size,Unit) = Unit * floor(Size / Unit);

	Protrusion = 0.1; // make holes end cleanly

	inch = 25.4;

	ID = 0;
	OD = 1;
	LENGTH = 2;

	//———————-
	// Useful routines

	module PolyCyl(Dia,Height,ForceSides=0) { // based on nophead's polyholes

	Sides = (ForceSides != 0) ? ForceSides : (ceil(Dia) + 2);

	FixDia = Dia / cos(180/Sides);

	cylinder(r=(FixDia + HoleWindage)/2,h=Height,$fn=Sides);
	}



	//* [Basic dimensions] */

	WallThick = 4.0; // min wall thickness

	Screw = [3.0,5.5,20.0]; // thread, head, length under head
	Insert = [3.0,4.1,8.0]; // thread, knurl, length

	//———————-
	// Brake tab cap

	BrakeTab = [15,21,3.1]; // length to wheel, width, thickness
	BrakeTabSagitta = 8.0; // height of curved endcap

	CapOAL = [BrakeTab.y + 2WallThick,BrakeTab.y + 2WallThick,BrakeTab.z + 2*WallThick];

	module TabCap() {

	difference() {
	rotate(180/8)
	cylinder(d=CapOAL.y,h=CapOAL.z,center=true,$fn=8);
	translate([BrakeTab.x/2,0,0])
	cube(BrakeTab,center=true);
	rotate(180/8)
	cylinder(d=BrakeTab.y/cos(180/8),h=BrakeTab.z,center=true,$fn=8);
	}
	}

	//———————-
	// Brake lever handle
	// Soft covering with rounded sides that we square off for simplicity

	HandleRibs = [15,34,14]; // ignoring slight taper from end
	HandleCore = [50.0,24.0,12.0]; // straight section of lever to top of ribs
	HandleTipWidth = 30.0; // ignoring actual sector height

	module Handle() {

	union() {
	hull() {
	rotate(180/8)
	cylinder(d=HandleTipWidth/cos(180/8),h=HandleCore.z,center=true,$fn=8);
	translate([-HandleCore.x/2,0,0])
	cube(HandleCore,center=true);
	}
	translate([-(3*HandleCore.x/2 – Protrusion),0,0]) // extend base for ball trimming
	cube(HandleCore,center=true);
	translate([-HandleRibs.x/2,0,0])
	cube(HandleRibs,center=true);
	}

	}

	//———————-
	// Support structure for handle cavity inside knob
	// Totally ad-hoc tweakage
	// Remember it's lying on its side to match the handle

	NumRibs = 2 + 1; // must be odd
	RibSpace = floor(HandleCore.z/(NumRibs + 1));

	module KnobSupport() {

	color("Yellow") { // support overlaps in the middle
	render(convexity=3)
	intersection() {
	for (k=[-1,1])
	translate([0,k*ThreadThick,0]) // shrink inward to break adhesion
	Handle();

	translate([(HandleCore.x – HandleRibs.x)/2 – HandleCore.x – Protrusion,0,0])
	cube([HandleCore.x – HandleRibs.x,HandleRibs.y,HandleCore.z],center=true);

	union()
	for (k=[-floor(NumRibs/2):floor(NumRibs/2)])
	translate([0,0,k* RibSpace])
	cube([2HandleCore.x,HandleRibs.y,2ThreadWidth],center=true);
	}

	translate([(HandleCore.x – HandleRibs.x)/2 – HandleCore.x,0,0])
	cube([HandleCore.x – HandleRibs.x,4ThreadWidth,NumRibsRibSpace],center=true);
	}
	}

	//———————-
	// Brake handle knob
	// Largely built with magic numbers
	// Includes support because it's not really optional

	KnobOD = 55.0;
	KnobOffset = HandleRibs.x/1;

	KnobSides = 243;

	module Knob() {

	difference() {
	hull() {
	resize([0,HandleRibs.y + 4*WallThick,HandleCore.x + HandleTipWidth/2 + WallThick])
	sphere(d=KnobOD,$fn=KnobSides);
	}

	translate([0,0,KnobOffset])
	rotate([0,-90,0])
	Handle();

	for (i=[-1,1],k=[-1,1])
	translate([iKnobOD/4,0,kKnobOD/4]) {
	rotate([90,0,0])
	PolyCyl(Insert[OD],1.5*Insert[LENGTH],6);
	translate([0,-Screw[LENGTH]/2,0])
	rotate([-90,0,0])
	PolyCyl(Screw[ID],KnobOD,6);
	translate([0,Screw[LENGTH] – Insert[LENGTH],0])
	rotate([-90,0,0])
	PolyCyl(Screw[OD],KnobOD,6);
	}
	}

	if (Support)
	translate([0,0,KnobOffset])
	rotate([0,-90,0])
	KnobSupport();

	}

	//———————-
	// Lash it together

	if (Layout == "TabCap") {
	TabCap();
	}

	if (Layout == "Handle") {
	Handle();
	}

	if (Layout == "Support") {
	KnobSupport();
	}

	if (Layout == "Knob") {
	Knob();
	}

	if (Layout == "Show") {
	translate([60,0,0])
	TabCap();
	Knob();
	}

	if (Layout == "Fit") {
	translate([60,0,0])
	difference() {
	TabCap();
	translate([0,0,CapOAL.z/2])
	cube(CapOAL,center=true);
	}
	difference() {
	Knob();
	translate([KnobOD + KnobOD/4,0*KnobOD,0])
	cube(2*KnobOD,center=true);
	translate([-KnobOD,-KnobOD,0])
	cube(2*KnobOD,center=true);
	}
	}

	if (Layout == "Build") {
	translate([KnobOD/2,0,(CapOAL.y*cos(180/8))/2])
	rotate([0,-90,90])
	TabCap();

	for (j=[-1,1])
	translate([0,-j0.75HandleCore.x,0])
	difference() {
	rotate([j*90,0,0])
	Knob();
	translate([0,0,-KnobOD])
	cube(2*KnobOD,center=true);
	}

	}

view raw Wheelchair Brake Mods.scad hosted with ❤ by GitHub

A doodle with dimensions of other parts:

Drive Wheelchair - brake footrest tab dimensions — Drive Wheelchair – brake footrest tab dimensions

The angled tab on the middle left is for the leg rest release latch, but I decided not to silk-purse-ize the thing.

2020-12-08