Ed Nisley's Blog: Shop notes, electronics, firmware, machinery, 3D printing, laser cuttery, and curiosities. Contents: 100% human thinking, 0% AI slop.
The discharge tests run at 250 mA, which is probably a bit low, as the HDR-AS30V camera can capture video for about two hours on a single battery. Given the Sony’s nominal 1.24 A·h (love that precision!) capacity and derating the Wasabi’s ambitious 1.6 A·h, two hours suggests a current around 500 mA would be more appropriate, but we’ll go with a lower current for now.
Oddly, the two Wasabi batteries (green & blue traces) outperform the Sony OEM battery (red and purple) in terms of voltage:
Sony NP-BX1 – OEM Wasabi – 2014-01-28
I can’t explain the small kink just before the big dropoff for both Wasabi batteries. Perhaps the protection circuitry behind the battery terminals has a slight peculiarity?
Looking at the total energy delivered, however:
Sony NP-BX1 – OEM Wasabi – Wh – 2014-01-28
The Sony battery says it’ll deliver 4.5 W·h and actually produces 4.8 W·h. The Wasabi batteries claim 5.7 W·h and don’t even come close at 4.25 W·h.
I cross-checked those results by importing the CSV data into a spreadsheet, computing the point-by-point power, finding the average, and then multiplying by the total test time in hours. Doing it a couple different ways says you can eyeball a reasonable value by multiplying the median voltage by the test current to get average wattage, then multiplying by the total test time to get W·h. That’s within a few percent, which is good enough for me.
The camera’s power supply undoubtedly has a low-voltage cutoff, but it’s a single-cell battery and they might just run it down around 2.8 V; in that case, the Sony batteries will last longer. If the voltage cutout is 3.5 V, similar to the Canon camera, then the Wasabi batteries win.
I don’t have enough experience with the camera or the batteries to predict anything based on actual use.
The Sony HDR-AS30V “action camera” uses NP-BX1 lithium batteries (3.7 V @ 1.24 A·h = 4.6 W·h) that are, of course, a completely different size and shape than any other lithium battery on the planet.
So.
Tweaking a few dimensions in the Canon NB-6L source code, tinkering with the layout of the contact pins, and shazam Yet Another 3D Printed Battery Test Fixture:
NP-BX1 Holder – show layout
It builds nicely, although the contact pin tunnels are a bit too close to the top of the case:
Sony NP-BX1 Holder – on platform
After reaming out the contact pin holes to the proper diameters & depths, then gluing the plugs in place, it works just as you’d expect:
Sony NP-BX1 battery holder
It’s worth noting that the Wasabi charger accepts the batteries upside-down, with the conspicuous chevron against the charger body. It’s definitely not the way all the other chargers work. The keying recesses on the battery (corresponding to the blocks in the solid model) lie along the bottom edge of the contact surface, so flipping the battery over means they’ll hold it in place, but … oh, well.
That grotty Powerpole connector last saw use in some random benchtop lashup. At some point I’ll be forced to start making more of those.
The pushbutton on the X10 wall switch controlling the fiercely incandescent lamp over the kitchen table has gotten erratic, so I dug into the Big Box o’ X10 Crap for a replacement. Turns out The Box has only 3-way switches, but the lamp needs a standard two-wire switch.
The instruction sheet shows this diagram:
X10 3-way Wall Switch Wiring
The pushbutton on the CS277 “Companion” switch connects the red lead to the two blue leads. The blue leads are always connected together and carry the lamp current, so the red lead is just a signal from the remote button.
The WS477 “Master” switch will work as an ordinary switch if you cap the red lead with a wire nut and tuck it into the box.
FC1002 Frequency Counter – faceplate – circular polarizer
A sheet of linear polarizing film held in front of the lens:
FC1002 Frequency Counter – faceplate – linear polarizer
For reference, none of the other instrument faceplates on the bench show anything other than uniform gray, with one exception that points directly to the plastic injection point.
I’d say this plate cracked due to unrelieved internal stresses and not anything I did or didn’t do.
Our Larval Engineer’s new camera uses Canon NB-6LH batteries, which have exactly the same nominal capacity as the NB-5L batteries for my camera, despite being not quite the same size. I cannot imagine any reason for that, other than brand fractionation, but there it is.
That hideous Powerpole thing came from one of the AA cell packs I’d been using to power the HTs on the bikes, before switching to lithium battery packs. It’s easier to harvest something suitable than to build a new thing, particularly for such a low duty cycle gadget.
This view of the solid model shows the contact pins, with the lid floating over its alignment pegs (made from snippets of 1.75 mm filament):
NB-6L Holder – fit layout
The pegs simplify gluing the lid in place, a process for which you can never have enough clamps:
Canon NB-6L holder – lid gluing
A cutaway shows the stepped holes around the contact pin, with the coil springs being the largest cylinder to the right of the solid-looking plug:
NB-6L Holder – show layout
The contact pins look like this, at least after one remembers to slide on all the parts before soldering the wires in place:
Canon NB-6L holder – contact pin detail
I filed off the inevitable solder bumps, rounded the butt ends with gentle suasion, and generally tidied the pins up so they’re smooth and symmetrical. The springs don’t have a lot of oomph, so wasting any force on friction or binding is a Bad Thing.
The holes require reaming with twist drills for a nice slip fit around the pins. The OpenSCAD script prints out the relevant diameters and depths:
ECHO: "Contact pin tip dia: 1.6"
ECHO: "Drill depth to taper end: 24.1 -- Dia: 2.4"
ECHO: " to ferrule end: 15 -- Dia: 3.1"
ECHO: " to plug end: 4 -- Dia: 5.2"
Grab the proper drill in a pin punch, adjust so that length protrudes, and have at it. Making the holes about 0.2 mm larger than nominal works well, although your mileage will definitely vary.
The build layout includes extra retaining plugs, as they tend to go walkabout under the bench:
NB-6L Holder – build layout
Add a dab of PVC cement with THF inside the holes and the plugs push firmly into place:
Our Larval Engineer reported that her camera, which is my old Casio pocket camera, has begun fading away, so we’re getting her a shiny new camera of her very own. Being a doting father, I picked up a pair of Wasabi NB-6L batteries (and a charger, it not costing much more for the package) so she’s never without electrons, and did the usual rundown test on all three batteries:
Canon NB-6L – 2014 OEM vs Wasabi
Fairly obviously, the Wasabi batteries aren’t first tier products, but they’re definitely better than that bottom-dollar crap from eBay.
