The Smell of Molten Projects in the Morning

Ed Nisley's Blog: Shop notes, electronics, firmware, machinery, 3D printing, laser cuttery, and curiosities. Contents: 100% human thinking, 0% AI slop.

Prusa MK4: Cart Coins vs. Extrusion Multiplier

A special request came in for cart coins with a handle:

Overstuffed cart key - 1.0EM
Overstuffed cart key – 1.0EM

That’s in gray PETG-CF (carbon fiber) with Extrusion Multiplier = 1.0 based on the Pill Tube tests and and slightly lower temperatures based on the temperature tower. It definitely looks overstuffed and so does the Wipe Tower for that set of six coins:

Overstuffed cart key - wipe tower
Overstuffed cart key – wipe tower

The orange threads off to the right suggest something went terribly wrong with the top layer, which corresponds to the somewhat recessed cart image in the coin, but there were no other symptoms.

All six of the next set failed completely:

Failed cart key - 1.0EM
Failed cart key – 1.0EM

Apparently the nozzle hit the clotted gray filament in the Wipe Tower and stalled the X axis motor:

Failed cart key - wipe tower
Failed cart key – wipe tower

That suggests the same thing happened to the first set during the last pass over the Wipe Tower, causing a less obvious failure.

Setting the Extrusion Multiplier = 0.65 produced a better result:

Cart key print - blue - 0.65EM
Cart key print – blue – 0.65EM

Albeit with a slightly understuffed top layer:

Cart key print - 0.65EM
Cart key print – 0.65EM

But not by much:

Cart key print - black - 0.65EM
Cart key print – black – 0.65EM

So the answer depends slightly on the PETG-CF filament color, but not by enough to justify defining three different filament types.

Cart coins are essentially solid plastic layers with no empty infill, so they have nowhere for excess filament to hide. The Wipe Tower should have plenty of room, but even at EM=0.65 the tower looks overstuffed on the side with the carbon fiber purge lines:

Cart key print 0.65EM - wipe towers
Cart key print 0.65EM – wipe towers

The default 110% line spacing in the tower seems too small for PETG-CF, so I’ll increase it to 150% to see if that reduces the clumping.

Judged by the surface finish, a 0.65 Extrusion Multiplier is too low, so I’ll try a set of coins at 0.80.

Comments

4 responses to “Prusa MK4: Cart Coins vs. Extrusion Multiplier”

  1. RCPete Avatar
    RCPete

    Cart keys haven’t made it to our corner of the world, and I’m hoping (against hope) that they won’t.

    The local method (Kroger, that I know of) uses fancy wheel locks. One mode locks a wheel if the cart is taken out of bounds, I assume over a buried signal line. Another mode locks that wheel if the cart didn’t pass by a register. False positives can be an issue, especially with self-check. Whee.

  2. Garden Hose Fitting Grip: MVP – The Smell of Molten Projects in the Morning Avatar

    […] the model as a 3mf file, importing it into PrusaSlicer, and slicing it with suitable parameters (Extrusion Multipler = 0.8) does what you’d expect. This top view shows the internal […]

  3. Laser-Engraved PETG / PETG-CF – The Smell of Molten Projects in the Morning Avatar

    […] blue PETG-CF from the scrap box, done at 500 mm/s and 20% of a 60 W laser and came out looking really […]