Ed Nisley's Blog: Shop notes, electronics, firmware, machinery, 3D printing, laser cuttery, and curiosities. Contents: 100% human thinking, 0% AI slop.
Which worked reasonably well for coasters with a rim around the perimeter to hold in the epoxy covering the entire top surface:
Printed Coaster Layout – solid model
The problem with smooth-top coasters is this:
Printed Coasters – epoxy fill
A slightly sweaty or wet mug can get a firm suction lock on that smooth top, lift the coaster off the table, then drop it into a plate of food.
So I put a rim around each fragment to separate the epoxy surfaces and break the suction lock:
Printed Coaster Layout – 5 inch Set B
Each recess has a narrow inner lip as a border inside the raised perimeter, which may not be strictly necessary, but IMO nicely sets off the fragments:
Smashed Glass 3D Printed Coaster – Set B
Each fragment must be spaced far enough from its three neighbors to allow for those lips and perimeter walls, which requires more fussing than I’m willing to apply on a regular basis.
So fetch & install Deepnest to fuss automagically. The program hasn’t been updated in years and the Linux version segfaults on my Manjaro boxen, but the Windows version runs fine on the Mini-PC I use for LightBurn:
Deepnest Fragment Set E – in progress
The Mini-PC runs maxi-hot, though, so at some point I must install Deepnest on the Token Windows Laptop for more grunt.
Deepnest requires a large shape representing the “sheet” in which to arrange the other pieces, so:
Import the fragments outlines into LightBurn
Create a suitable circle
Export circle + fragments as an SVG file
Import into Deepnest
Set 5 mm spacing & other suitable parameters
Let it grind until a nice arrangement pops out
Save as Yet Another SVG file
The output SVG has the fragment outlines arranged to fit within the circle, but does not include the circle. That’s fine, because the next step involves creating a conformal perimeter around the entire group of fragments and preparing it for input to OpenSCAD to create a solid model:
Printed Coaster Layout – 5 inch Set C – solid model
Because all smashed glass fragments are different, the problem boils down to locating their borders in order to create recesses to hold them.
The fragments, being slightly green-tinted glass, have very low contrast against any background color. This picture shows the result of applying GIMP’s Select by color tool with a reasonable color tolerance:
Printed Fragment Coaster – 5 inch – GIMP mask
Fiddling with the tolerance trades off more trash outside the fragments with less accurate selection inside them. While it’s possible to clean up the ensuing mess, it’s incredibly tedious and more trouble than just tracing the edges manually using a stylus and graphic tablet. For the record, a white background produces similar results.
I began tracing the fragments with meticulous attention to following their exact outline, which certainly produced angular shapes:
Smashed Glass paths – quick mask
It also takes approximately forever and is way tedious.
The intent was to apply a uniform offset to those outlines in OpenSCAD, but it turned out the fragment edges aren’t exactly perpendicular to the scanner platform and the protruding glass extends beyond any reasonable offset; determining how unreasonable the offset must be requires cutting a fitting template:
Printed Coasters – fit test
Incidentally, the dark smudge in the bottom fragment isn’t dirt, it’s the Ford logo above the identification numbers for that particular window:
Printed Coasters – glass fragment logo
You’ll note the rather sloppy fit inside the template.
However, the little glass shard sticking out on the upper right side does not match a corresponding template notch. You’re looking at the top of the fragment, but the scanner was looking at the bottom and that shard angles outward toward the top, where it was out of focus and I didn’t notice it.
Although that fragment fit its recess, such things eventually cause problems:
Printed Coasters – fragment misalignment
The chipboard template isn’t as tall as the printed recess, which means some of those protruding shards can wiggle through.
Protip: Avoid the temptation to just press a fragment into its ill-fitting recess, as shattered glass doesn’t have much strength. AFAICT, only air pressure holds the shards in place (they’re not windshields and not laminated), so you must handle them like they’re made of ahem glass.
The scans produce 300 DPI images, so each pixel is 0.085 mm across and half a millimeter is about 6 pixels wide. I tried tracing the fragments with the center of a 12 pixel circular GIMP brush, so the outer edge of the brush painted a 0.5 mm margin around the fragment, but keeping the middle of the brush on the edge was entirely too fussy.
I eventually settled on a 6 pixel brush, painted it just outside the margin, and paid more attention to shadows that might be shards protruding toward the top:
Printed Clutter Collector – fragment GIMP selection
That works out well with the fragments on the desk to resolve any issues.
The garish red in those screenshots is GIMP’s Quick Mask mode allowing you (well, me) to paint the selection with either black or white to mask or select the pixels.
After painting the entire perimeter of the fragment, use the Bucket Fill tool to pour white into the interior and select the entire fragment. This is much easier than scribbling over the fragment, which is what I did until I realized I was working too hard.
I sprayed the white-ish fragments (on the left) with satin-finish clear rattlecan “paint” in the hopes it would keep epoxy out of the cracks between the glass cuboids and leave the highly reflective air gaps. While it did a reasonable job of sealing, it bonded poorly with the epoxy and produced a dull surface finish.
The unsprayed fragments (on the right) turned out better, although the one in the upper right has a thin air bubble / layer on top. The unsealed cracks between the cuboids show well against the reflective layers, so I think spraying the fragments isn’t worth the effort.
The printed base has a 1 mm tall rim to retain the epoxy:
Printed Coaster Layout – solid model
I mixed enough epoxy to fill half the volume of a disk with the same overall OD and depth (V = h × π × d²/4), which turned out to be barely enough produce a level surface at the rim. There didn’t seem that much epoxy left on the various measuring / mixing cups, but next time I’ll round upward.
Many of the bubbles emerged from below the metalized paper, as well as between the glass and paper, so next time:
Set up a level platform with a sacrificial cover
Omit the adhesive sheet under the metallized paper
Pour a little epoxy into the recesses
Squish the metallized paper into place
Pour more epoxy to cover the paper
Gently squish the glass fragments into place
Ease more epoxy around the fragments
Chivvy the bubbles away
Fill to the rim
The top isn’t exactly flat and has some dull areas, so at some point I want to make it flat with 220 grit sandpaper, work up to some 3000 grit paper I’ve been saving for a special occasion, then finish it off with Novus polish. Which seems like enough hassle to keep the coaster under my sippy cup for a while.
The motivation for making Yet Another Coaster was to see if combining a few techniques I’ve recently learned would produce a nicer result.
Spoiler: Yup, with more to be learned and practiced.
This is a somewhat nonlinear narrative reminding me of things to do and not do in the future, so don’t treat it as a direct how-to set of instructions.
The glass fragments sit inside holes in the next two (or three or whatever) acrylic layers, which must have a total thicknesses slightly more than the glass thickness andremain properly aligned while assembling the whole stack:
Smashed Glass Coaster 5 – alignment pin
Bonus: all that cutting generates an absurd amount of acrylic scrap. I eventually put much of it to good use, but not producing it in the first place would be a Good Thing …
So 3D print the entire base, which requires generating a solid model with recesses for the fragments:
Printed Coaster Layout – solid model
Because there’s no real justification for an optical-quality mirror under smashed glass, use reflective metallized paper in the recesses as reflectors:
Smashed glass printed coaster – metallized paper assembly
The glass is more-or-less greenish-blueish, so I used a strip of green metallized paper that made the glass fragments green. Obviously there’s some room for choice down there.
Both the base and the reflectors use outlines of the fragments, so I started with a scan of the approximate layout in GIMP:
Smashed Glass – 4in – group A – tweaked
I traced the outline of each fragment using the Scissors Select Tool, which lays line segments along the sharpest gradient between clicked points, then switched into Quick Mask mode to adjust & smooth the results:
Smashed Glass paths – quick mask
That’s the result after sketching & saving all the paths as separate SVG files to allow importing them individually into InkScape, OpenSCAD, and LightBurn.
Which turned out to be suboptimal, as it let me write an off-by-one blooper omitting the last file from the OpenSCAD model:
A better choice puts all the paths into a single named group, saved as a single SVG file, then importing that group from the file using its name, along these lines:
It’s not clear if I can do that directly from GIMP by saving all the paths in a single file, then importing that lump into Inkscape as a group, but it’ll go something like that.
After getting the fragment paths into Inkscape, add a 0.5 mm offset to each path to clear any non-vertical edges. This will be checked with the template cut using LightBurn as described below.
Add a 1 mm rim around the outside, with the 4 inch OD matching the usual PSA cork base:
Fragment layout – 4in
Now’s the time to nudge / rotate the outlines so they have at least a millimeter of clearance on all sides / ends, because that’s about as thin a section of printed plastic as you want.
Locating the center of the OD (and, thus, everything inside) at the lower-left corner of the Inkscape page will put them at the OpenSCAD origin. I have set Inkscape to have its origin at the lower left, rather than the default upper left, so your origin may vary.
Select one of the paths:
Fragment layout – Inkscape A
Then set the ID in its Object Properties:
Fragment layout – Inkscape A – properties
There is an interaction between the name over in the Layers and Objects window, which apparently comes from the GIMP path name for the imported fragments, and the resulting ID and Label in the Object Properties window. However, renaming an object on the left, as for the Rim and Perimeter circles, does not set their ID or Label on the right. Obviously, I have more learning to do before this goes smoothly.
With everything laid out and named and saved in an SVG file, the OpenSCAD program is straightforward (and now imports all the fragments):
Which squirts out the solid model appearing above.
Feeding it into PrusaSlicer turns the model into something printable:
Printed Coaster Layout – slicer
And after supper I had one in my hands.
Before doing that, however, import the same SVG file into LightBurn, as on the left:
Printed Coaster Layout – LightBurn
On the right, duplicate it, put the inner Rim on a tool layer, put the rest on a layer set to cut chipboard, and make a template to verify those holes fit around the fragments:
Smashed glass printed coaster – fragment test fit
Which a few didn’t, explaining why I go to all that trouble. Iterate through GIMP → paths → SVG → Inkscape → LightBurn until it’s all good. Obviously, you do this before you get too far into OpenSCAD, but they all derive from the Inkscape layout, so there’s not a lot of wasted motion.
The middle LightBurn layout insets the fragment outlines by 0.25 mm to ensure the paper fits easily and puts them on a layer set to cut metallized paper. Those fragments then get duplicated and rearranged within the rectangle on the top to fit a strip of metallized paper from the scrap box. Fire The Laser to cut them out and stick them to the bottom of their corresponding 3D printed recesses with leftover snippets of craft adhesive sheet as shown above.
I had originally intended to cover the bottom of the entire sheet of metallized paper with an adhesive sheet, but realized the whole affair was going to be submerged in epoxy, so just making sure the paper didn’t float away would suffice.
Having recently had to move the flat box of shattered glass to get something from behind it, I figured I could apply new techniques to old material :
Smashed glass printed coaster – oblique view
This is something of a test case to restart the whole process, so it has a few bloopers. This post covers the results, with more detail on the process to follow.
Arrange some good-looking shattered glass fragments within the 4 inch circle on the fixture:
Smashed glass printed coaster – fragment test fit
Scan it, trace the outlines into paths using GIMP, label the paths in Inkscape, import into LightBurn to laser-cut the chipboard disk in that picture to verify enough clearance around the fragments, import into OpenSCAD, and produce a solid model for PrusaSlicer:
Printed Coaster Layout – slicer
While it’s printing, laser-cut green metallized paper to serve as a reflecting layer below the glass, then affix the paper to the bottom of the recesses:
Smashed glass printed coaster – metallized paper assembly
During that process I discovered one of the fragment recesses didn’t make it from the Inkscape SVG file to the OpenSCAD model:
Smashed glass printed coaster – missing fragment
Like I said: bloopers. That fragment now has its place in the OpenSCAD code and the slicer preview above, not that I have matching fragments to build another one.
Put all but one fragment in their places, pour clear epoxy over everything, pop bubbles for a while, then let it cure overnight:
Smashed glass printed coaster – front view
Stick a PSA cork disk on the bottom and it’s ready for service.
Which looks OK-ish, although not significantly different from the straight-hole versions:
Layered Paper – tapered blocks
The taper shows off the layer colors along the sides of the holes:
Layered Paper – tapered blocks – oblique detail
Unfortunately, it also makes the corner blemishes painfully obvious:
Layered Paper – tapered blocks – detail
My first attempt didn’t skootch the squares over by the size of the inset, thus neatly aligning the upper left corners and giving the bottom right corners twice the inset:
Layered Paper – tapered blocks – fixed origin – detail
Which made those gnarly corners painfully obvious.
I tried stacking the sheets with their bottom side upward, hoping to disguise the edge charring, but to no avail.
The inset code remains in place with a default of zero: